Made in USA Skincare: Final Fill in the US Is Not Enough for FTC
Filling, compounding or finishing a skincare product in the United States does not, on its own, support an unqualified “Made in USA” claim on the label. Under the Federal Trade Commission’s Made in USA Labeling Rule, domestic final assembly is the minimum threshold, not the test. The FTC restated that on November 17, 2026, in its fourth Made in USA enforcement action of the year, against a manufacturer whose products were assembled domestically but built largely from imported inputs.
What the FTC did on November 17
The Commission announced a proposed settlement with Elk River Inc., an Alabama maker of fall-protection harnesses, over claims that its harnesses were “Made in USA,” “American-made” and “#madeinalabama.” Final assembly happened in Alabama. According to the FTC’s complaint, most components and materials — including parts essential to the safe function of the harness — came from outside the United States. The proposed order carries a $4.4 million judgment, suspended after a payment of $72,527 on inability-to-pay grounds, and bans unqualified US-origin claims the company cannot substantiate. The case is not about harnesses. It is about the gap between “we make it here” and “all or virtually all of it is from here” — a gap skincare sits squarely inside, because a finished cosmetic is mostly purchased inputs.
The three-part test, and where cosmetics usually fail it
The rule is short. 16 CFR 323.2 makes it a deceptive practice to label a product “Made in the United States” unless all three of the following are true: final assembly or processing occurs in the United States; all significant processing that goes into the product occurs in the United States; and all or virtually all ingredients or components are made and sourced in the United States.
FTC guidance adds that foreign content must be no more than negligible, and that the Commission weighs the share of total manufacturing cost attributable to US parts and processing, how far removed foreign content is from the finished product, and how important it is to the product’s form or function.
Apply that to a serum. The water, the compounding, the fill and the labor may all be domestic. The peptide, the encapsulated retinoid, the preservative system and the pump frequently are not — and they are the reason the customer bought it. A brand that cannot document where each was made has no reasonable basis for an unqualified claim, and civil penalties under the rule run up to $53,088 per violation.
The raw-material exception is narrower than founders think
There is a carve-out, and it is commonly over-read. In the preamble to the 2021 rule, the Commission repeats its position that where a raw material is not found or grown in the United States and is not the essence of the finished product, consumers read a “Made in USA” claim as meaning everything except that material originated here. The FTC’s example is vanilla beans in ice cream.
The next sentence is the one that matters: the guidance applies only to raw materials, not manufactured inputs. A botanical that cannot be grown domestically is one conversation. A synthesized active or a finished fragrance compound bought from an overseas house is a manufactured input, and it counts against the claim.
Packaging sits on a less settled line. In a 2020 closing letter on adhesive products, FTC staff said the Commission has not generally required marketers to account for incidental packaging that has no independent value and is discarded once the product is used up, unless the marketer’s own claims suggest the packaging is domestic. That is staff guidance in one matter, not a rule. A folding carton is plainly incidental; an airless pump a brand markets as a feature is harder to call incidental, because the brand has already told the consumer it has value.
California attaches a number the FTC never did
The FTC has deliberately avoided a percentage threshold. California has one. Under Business and Professions Code section 17533.7, merchandise sold in the state may not carry “Made in U.S.A.” or similar wording if it was entirely or substantially made outside the United States. Foreign parts are tolerated at no more than 5 percent of final wholesale value — or up to 10 percent where the manufacturer shows the part can neither be produced in the US nor obtained from a domestic source, a showing that cannot rest on cost. Any brand selling nationwide online is selling into California, so the stricter number governs in practice.
Practical takeaways for brand owners
- Get country of origin on every raw material, component and closure before the claim goes on a label, not after a complaint arrives.
- Separate where the work happened from where the product came from. “Manufactured in our Chatsworth, California facility” describes a process; “Made in USA” describes the whole product.
- Use a qualified claim when the unqualified one is not supportable: “Made in USA with US and imported ingredients” is legal if true and the last substantial transformation was domestic.
- Do not spread one product’s claim across a line. A page saying “our products are made in the USA” covers every product on it.
- Date the substantiation file — a supplier switch can quietly invalidate a claim nobody rewrote.
Frequently asked questions
Does compounding and filling in the US make a skincare product “Made in USA”? No. Domestic final processing is required, but the rule also demands all significant processing and all or virtually all ingredients and components be domestic.
Is a US-registered facility enough? No. FDA facility registration under MoCRA is a separate obligation and says nothing about ingredient origin. It is registration, not approval.
Moe’s Group formulates, fills and labels skincare, hair care and body care in Chatsworth, California, and can supply component and raw-material origin documentation for a project on request. If you are deciding what your label can honestly say, start a product inquiry and bring the formula.
— The Moe’s Group Newsroom